tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4476787828976554058.post1022315520257754192..comments2023-10-05T06:46:34.302-04:00Comments on Views From The Longbox: EPISODE 253 - LEGENDS...30 YEARS LATER PART 1Michael Baileyhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/15801975065448631610noreply@blogger.comBlogger4125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4476787828976554058.post-18534314568950987012016-12-28T14:03:40.402-05:002016-12-28T14:03:40.402-05:00Hi Michael! I've just listened to this episode...Hi Michael! I've just listened to this episode, my first of Views from the Long Box. I've been exploring other podcasts since the end of Ryan Daly's Secret Origins 'cast, and finally go here! This was a terrific listen! (Glad I didn't have to go to work today!) I got to hear the secret origins of Ryan, and Chad, and Siskoid! There a couple of things I'd like to comment on. I'm a pre-Crisis DC fan. Legends pretty much marks the end of my regular monthly collecting. I really liked Earth-2 and the 30th century and a Superman who was Superboy and who could bend his knees and elbows. (Byrne's S-man almost never did. Also his Phantom Stranger bugged me. I prefer my Stranger to have his eyes in complete shadow, no white eyes.) A lot of the very fine folks doing these podcasts seem to have very little knowledge of the stories from the late 70s-early 80s. When you were discussing The Penguin, you claimed that he was in need of updating. I recall that Doug Moench had tried to do that in a couple of stories in 1984, but like other ideas and concepts, it was ignored or forgotten by subsequent writers. re: Captain Marvel; I was just listening to Rob Kelly's Treasury podcast and he was wondering aloud why Billy's lightning never caused any damage, and here in this Legends story it does! But, I say it can't. It is magic lightning. Non-flammable. So there. I didn't much like Legends. Even then it felt contrived and forced. One final thing re: Cosmic Boy. I really like Siskoid, at least as much as I know him as a blogger and podcaster, but I disagree with him about the use if the Challenger disaster. That panel has really stayed with me all these years. (That never happened! That never happened!) It is true that 1986 was already not matching up to the future envisioned in the early 60's, but that event really seemed to put a halt to "big progress." As the editorial future had now been changed as a result of The Crisis, it seemed appropriate that such a recognizable event could used so effectively in this story.<br />Legends was meant to make sense of the new unified DC universe, but the timeline was still messed up at this point. Man of Steel, a contemporaneous book, was supposed to have taken place years earlier. But how many years? Did Superman go public before Batman? How old does that make Dick Grayson? What adventures had they had? Wonder Woman is brand new at the end of Legends. So are ALL Justice League Stories void? They never did satisfactorily settle on who or what Hawkman was. And yet, and yet...Mr. Terrific remained murdered. Even though there may never have been a Justice League satellite or JLA/JSA teamups! <br />Okay. I'm done for now. I look forward to hearing the rest of this series and exploring some of your older 'casts!Ward Hill Terryhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/17970929316613767454noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4476787828976554058.post-42342016391360933722016-11-27T12:29:32.284-05:002016-11-27T12:29:32.284-05:00Mark: You bring up a great point. To the general ...Mark: You bring up a great point. To the general public the process would look safe considering there wasn't a huge fallout cloud poisoning the area. So it was more a Three Mile Island and not a Chernobyl.<br /><br />Tim: Thanks for the kind words. Hopefully you made it through the first part and noticed the second part is a bit shorter. Also, thanks for the memories and I now need to check out your coverage of the Blue Beetle issues now that my coverage is done and dusted.Michael Baileyhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15801975065448631610noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4476787828976554058.post-57344760798634195312016-11-16T14:52:36.925-05:002016-11-16T14:52:36.925-05:00This is quite an undertaking...on both sides! lol ...This is quite an undertaking...on both sides! lol I'm sure it wasn't easy to put it all together to record, and if this episode alone is any indication, it's going to be a bit of work to get thru...but amazing work it will be! I covered the Blue Beetle crossovers on my blog a while back, and have always had great memories of Legends as a whole myself. I started collecting comics right after Crisis, so Legends provided many firsts; my first crossover "event", first introduction to the Legion (via the Cosmic Boy mini which I covered over at the Legion of Super-bloggers), my first "new" Justice League (I was just getting to know the Detroit League when they were offed), my introduction to the Suicide Squad...I could go on and on...<br /><br />Anyway, great stuff which I have to get back to listening to! Can't wait to hear the rest of your coverage!Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04412102788735931123noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4476787828976554058.post-73537660933562559922016-11-16T11:53:53.629-05:002016-11-16T11:53:53.629-05:00When discussing Legends #1, Shag questioned Jenet ...When discussing Legends #1, Shag questioned Jenet Klyburn's judgement by praising Professor Stein as having been behind the Hudson Nuclear Power Plant, which as Shag rightly notes, blew up.<br /><br />But consider this: Stein's main purpose behind the Hudson Plant was to attempt to demonstrate a "safe" nuclear power plant. While that might be considered a failure because... well, it didn't exist for very long, the very fact that it *was* blown up, yet the surrounding area is not considered a radioactive wasteland, can easily be considered proof that Stein's claims of safety were sound. (The fact that Firestorm absorbed all of that radioactivity into himself need not be commonly known to the general populace)Mark Baker-Wrighthttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14593390925694976101noreply@blogger.com